By Matthew T. Latham, ISA Board Certified Master Arborist, ASCA Registered Consulting Arborist | Arborist on Demand, LLC
Imagine receiving a letter informing you that a utility company intends to acquire an easement across your property. Maybe it’s for a high-voltage transmission line, an underground pipeline, a highway expansion, or another infrastructure project.
You discover that a portion of your land will be permanently affected, construction equipment may cross your property, and dozens of mature trees could be removed.
Naturally, you begin asking questions.
What happens to the trees? Who determines their value? Does the company’s offer account for everything you’re losing?
These are questions I’ve been hearing more frequently in my work as a consulting arborist.
Recently, I’ve been involved in several eminent domain matters where property owners are facing the potential loss of substantial numbers of mature trees. Some have spent decades enjoying wooded properties, only to discover that a proposed utility corridor could dramatically change their landscape.
What concerns me is how easily the trees themselves can become an overlooked part of the conversation.
Before those trees are removed, it’s important to understand what you’re losing, how that loss can be professionally documented, and why timing matters.
Eminent Domain: More Than Just a Strip of Land

Eminent domain is the legal authority to acquire private property for a qualifying public use, subject to applicable legal requirements, including just compensation.
Although the specific laws and procedures vary by jurisdiction, eminent domain projects occur throughout the United States.
Common examples include:
- Electrical transmission and distribution corridors
- Oil and natural gas pipelines
- Highway construction and roadway widening
- Municipal utility and drainage infrastructure
- Public transportation and other infrastructure improvements
In many cases, the acquiring entity doesn’t need to purchase the entire property. Instead, it may acquire an easement granting specific rights to use a portion of the land.
A permanent easement may restrict what can be planted, built, or maintained within the designated corridor.
A temporary construction easement may allow equipment access, excavation, grading, material storage, or other activities during construction.
While these easements serve different purposes, both can have significant consequences for existing trees.
And those consequences aren’t always limited to the trees directly within the easement.

The Trees You Lose May Represent Decades of Growth
Consider a mature oak tree that has been growing on a property for 75 years.
It may provide substantial shade, screen neighboring properties, contribute to the landscape’s appearance, and help define the character of the property.
Now imagine losing 20, 30, or even 50 mature trees to a utility corridor.
Replacing those trees isn’t as simple as purchasing the same number of young trees from a nursery.
Large, established trees often cannot be practically replaced with specimens of equivalent size, structure, and maturity. Even where replacement planting is possible, it may take decades to restore comparable benefits.
From an arboricultural standpoint, mature trees can provide several important functions:
Shade and temperature moderation. Large tree canopies intercept sunlight and can help reduce heat exposure around homes and outdoor living areas.
Privacy and visual screening. Trees can provide natural separation from roads, neighboring properties, and infrastructure.
Stormwater interception and soil protection. Canopies intercept rainfall, while roots contribute to soil structure and stability.
Landscape character and environmental benefits. Established trees contribute to the appearance, ecological function, and usability of a property.
These functions are relevant when evaluating tree loss. However, their existence does not automatically mean each benefit qualifies for separate monetary compensation in an eminent domain proceeding.
That distinction is important.
Are Property Owners Entitled to Compensation for Their Trees?
This is one of the most common questions I encounter, and the answer requires some explanation.
Trees can contribute to the value and utility of real property, but their appraised arboricultural value is not necessarily an additional amount that a property owner can recover in an eminent domain case.

In many condemnation proceedings, compensation is evaluated primarily through real estate valuation principles, including the value of the property rights acquired and, where legally applicable, damages to the remaining property.
The applicable rules depend on whether the acquisition is governed by federal or state law and the circumstances of the particular taking.
For example, a mature stand of trees may provide privacy screening between a residence and a roadway. Removing those trees could change the character and market appeal of the remaining property.
A qualified real estate appraiser may need to evaluate whether that change produces a measurable effect on the property’s market value.
My role as a consulting arborist is different.
I identify and evaluate the trees, document their condition and functions, assess the likely consequences of removal or construction damage, and develop arboricultural opinions that can assist attorneys and real estate appraisers.
A tree appraisal and a real estate appraisal answer different questions. Used appropriately, they can provide complementary evidence.
How Are Mature Trees Professionally Appraised?
Tree appraisal is a specialized discipline that applies established valuation principles and methods to trees and other landscape plants.
One widely recognized reference is the Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition, Revised, developed by the Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers (CTLA).
Depending on the assignment and intended use, a professional appraisal may consider approaches involving cost, income, or sales comparison.
For large, established trees, one potential method is the Trunk Formula Technique (TFT).
This technique can estimate a tree’s depreciated reproduction cost by considering characteristics such as its trunk size, relevant nursery pricing, physical condition, and functional and external limitations.
A proper evaluation involves considerably more than measuring trunk diameter and assigning a dollar amount.
For example, I may document:
- Species: The type of tree and its suitability to the location.
- Size: Trunk diameter, canopy dimensions, and other relevant measurements.
- Condition: Tree health, structural integrity, and overall form.
- Function: The role the tree serves within the landscape.
- Site limitations: Conditions affecting the tree’s suitability, usefulness, or potential performance.
- External influences: Factors outside the tree itself that may affect the appraisal conclusion.

The selected appraisal method must be appropriate for the assignment, and the results must be interpreted within their intended context.
Importantly, a calculated tree reproduction cost should not automatically be presented as the amount owed in a condemnation proceeding.
That is a legal and real estate valuation question requiring additional analysis.
What About Trees That Aren’t Being Removed?
This is an issue I believe deserves considerably more attention.
When people think about utility easements, they usually focus on the trees that will be cut down.
However, construction activities can also affect trees that remain standing outside the clearing limits.
Tree roots frequently extend well beyond the visible canopy and are not confined to property lines or easement boundaries.
Excavation, grading, soil compaction, and changes in drainage can damage root systems even when the tree’s trunk is located outside the construction corridor.
Potential impacts include:

Root severance. Excavation can remove structural and absorbing roots, potentially affecting stability, water uptake, and long-term health.
Soil compaction. Heavy machinery can reduce soil pore space, limiting oxygen availability and water infiltration in the rooting environment.
Grade changes. Adding or removing soil can alter conditions around roots and interfere with normal root function.
Canopy removal. Severe pruning or clearing of adjacent vegetation can alter a tree’s structure, exposure, and growing environment.
Delayed decline. Construction-related damage may not produce obvious symptoms immediately. Some trees can exhibit progressive decline over subsequent growing seasons.
In my consulting work, I’ve encountered situations where trees remaining outside a proposed corridor may experience substantial root or canopy impacts.
These trees deserve consideration, too.
A tree that remains standing after construction is not necessarily a tree that remains unaffected.
Why Documenting Trees Before Construction Is So Important
One of the most difficult aspects of forensic arboriculture is reconstructing conditions after the evidence has been removed.
Once a tree is cut down, it may become impossible to accurately determine its previous canopy structure, health, structural condition, or contribution to the surrounding landscape.
Photographs can help, but they rarely provide all the information needed for a comprehensive professional assessment.
That’s why I strongly encourage property owners to consider an independent tree inventory before clearing or construction begins.
A professional inventory may include species identification, trunk measurements, condition assessments, photographs, georeferenced locations, and documentation of relevant landscape functions.
Where appropriate, the assignment may also include an appraisal analysis, an evaluation of potential construction impacts, or a tree preservation assessment.
The goal is to establish a reliable record of existing conditions before those conditions change.
This documentation may help distinguish pre-existing defects from construction-related damage and provide supporting evidence for attorneys, appraisers, insurers, or other professionals.
Even when litigation never occurs, having a well-documented baseline can be valuable.
What Should You Do If Your Property Is Facing Eminent Domain?
If you’ve received notice of a proposed easement or property acquisition, there are several practical steps worth considering.
1. Obtain and review the proposed easement documents.
Pay attention to the proposed boundaries, access rights, vegetation restrictions, and whether the project includes temporary construction areas.
2. Photograph the property before any clearing begins.
Capture wide views of wooded areas, individual mature trees, existing landscape screening, and the relationship between trees and nearby structures.
3. Preserve existing records.
Historical photographs, surveys, aerial imagery, landscape plans, and prior tree assessments may help establish pre-construction conditions.
4. Consider an independent arboricultural evaluation.
A consulting arborist experienced in tree appraisal and construction impacts can help document the existing vegetation and identify potentially significant losses or damage.
5. Consult an attorney experienced in eminent domain law.
An attorney familiar with the applicable jurisdiction can explain your legal rights, relevant deadlines, and how arboricultural evidence may fit into a compensation claim.
Ideally, these steps should occur before the property is cleared or materially disturbed.
An Independent Perspective Matters
As an ISA Board Certified Master Arborist and ASCA Registered Consulting Arborist, my responsibility is to provide objective, technically supported opinions based on the available evidence.
That responsibility does not change depending on who retains me.
Whether I’m working with a property owner, attorney, or another party involved in a dispute, my conclusions must remain grounded in accepted arboricultural principles, appropriate appraisal methodology, and the specific facts of the assignment.
In eminent domain matters, that means evaluating both the trees scheduled for removal and those potentially affected by construction.
It also means recognizing the limits of an arboricultural appraisal and working within the broader legal and real estate valuation process.
My goal isn’t to inflate a claim or promise a particular outcome.
My goal is to make sure the trees, their condition, their functions, and the potential consequences of their loss are accurately documented and professionally evaluated.
Your Trees May Be Gone in a Day. The Evidence Shouldn’t Disappear With Them.
One of the most striking things about mature trees is how long they take to develop compared with how quickly they can be removed.
A tree that has grown for generations can be cut down in a matter of minutes.
And once it’s gone, much of the evidence needed to evaluate it may be gone as well.
If your property is facing a proposed utility easement, pipeline, roadway expansion, or other eminent domain action, consider having your trees independently evaluated before construction begins.
You may not be able to prevent every tree from being removed.
But you can take steps to ensure that their existence, condition, and significance to your property are properly documented.
Nationwide Eminent Domain Tree Appraisal & Arboricultural Consulting
Arborist on Demand, LLC provides independent arboricultural consulting, tree inventories, appraisal analysis, construction impact assessments, forensic investigations, and expert witness services for property owners, attorneys, and other parties involved in eminent domain and property damage matters throughout the United States.
Services may include preliminary remote consultations, document reviews, on-site inspections, technical reporting, and litigation support.
About the Author

Matthew T. Latham, BCMA, RCA is the owner of Arborist on Demand, LLC, providing independent arboricultural consulting nationwide. As an ISA Board Certified Master Arborist (#TX-3737B), ASCA Registered Consulting Arborist (#859), and qualified Tree and Plant Appraiser, he specializes in forensic investigations, tree appraisals, eminent domain assessments, construction-related tree damage, and expert witness services.
Learn more: www.arboristondemand.com
Email: in**@**************nd.com
Matthew T. Latham, BCMA #TX-3737B | ASCA RCA #859 | Tree & Plant Appraisal Qualified | ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualified
Disclaimer: This article is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice or a determination of compensation entitlement. Eminent domain laws and valuation requirements vary by jurisdiction. Property owners should consult qualified legal counsel regarding their specific circumstances.
